MOVIE · 2025
Eye for an Eye
Horror101 min
After the sudden death of her parents, Anna relocates from New York to a small Florida town to live with the grandmother she has never met. Isolated and looking for a foothold, she falls in with two local teens and becomes complicit in a brutal act she can’t undo. Whitney Peak leads Anna’s story as grief and guilt give way to something more nightmarish: Mr. Sandman, the spirit of a tormented child who haunts bullies in their dreams before taking their eyes when they wake. Golda Rosheuvel and Finn Bennett are part of the town closing around her as Anna tries to break the curse before it turns on her.
Find out what fits your taste.
Rate movies and shows in ReelRecs, save your next watch, and get personal recommendations from the Reel Recs online service. Free on iPhone and Android.
Where to watch in US
These offers have not all been recently verified. Check the provider for current availability.
Included with a subscription
Free
- Kanopy
Rent
- Amazon Prime Video
- Apple TV
- Fandango At Home
- Google Play Movies
- YouTube
Buy
- Amazon Prime Video
- Apple TV
- Fandango At Home
- Google Play Movies
- YouTube
Availability checked October 24, 2026. Offers can change. Rentals and purchases are separate from subscriptions.
More to consider
Kill Me Again (2025)
Charlie, a notorious serial killer known as the Midnight Mangler, finds himself trapped in a loop, reliving the same violent night over and over. At first he leans into the carnage, but repetition turns the night into a…
Obsession (2026)
Bear, a music store employee and hopeless romantic, breaks the mysterious One Wish Willow to make his childhood friend Nikki fall in love with him. He gets exactly what he asked for, but the wish quickly twists into som…
Keeper (2025)
An anniversary weekend at a secluded cabin turns into a nightmare when Malcolm abruptly heads back to the city, leaving Liz alone in the woods with a malevolent presence and a house full of secrets. Tatiana Maslany is L…
Catalogue checked October 30, 2026. Use ReelRecs with an assistant